Little merit in creating ARC at this stage, no final decision yet, says government

India economy

The government on Thursday said that there was little merit in creating an asset reconstruction company (ARC) at this stage. However, no final decision has been taken yet.

The draft report by the bankers’ panel headed by Sunil Mehta, chairman of Punjab National Bank, has been submitted to the finance ministry which is yet to be examined in detail.

The entire ARC model will have to function as per the RBI regulation.

 5 Minutes Read

IDBI Bank will be a subsidiary and not merged into LIC

KV Prasad Jun 13, 2022, 06:35 AM IST (Published)

 Listen to the Article (6 Minutes)

Summary

Sources say selling bank to a private investor at this juncture may not get the best value for government. 

SAPNA DAS

The government is in favour of selling its majority stake in IDBI Bank to state-owned insurance company LIC, as it fears private players may acquire the stake at low cost, sources said.

The bank’s current valuation was not reflective of its inherent value, according to the centre, the sources added.

“Selling the bank to a private investor at this juncture may not get the best value for the government,” a person with knowledge of the matter said.

“Private insurance companies are also wary of strong institutions like LIC with bancassurance through IDBI Bank’s network,” the source added.

While many any private buyers are eyeing the opportunity, the government is not keen on the same. Two private banks reportedly have shown interest in picking up strategic stake in the bank.

IDBI Bank’s real estate assets are worth about Rs 7000 crore, while its non core assets, which include investments in NSE, NSDL, IDBI Federal Life, IDBI Mutual Fund and IDBI Capital Markets, are also valued around Rs 7000 crore.

The market cap of the bank is around Rs 24,000 crore. The government also expects the additional provisioning requirement for the bank to reduce on NCLT resolutions in high value accounts.

“IDBI Bank is in the process of a turnaround and is expected to show profits soon. Therefore, the present approach is expected to give a big upside to LIC when IDBI Bank’s valuations rise. It will also give a good upside to the government as well, as and when it decides to divest its shareholding. LIC will also bring down its stake over the years, as prescribed by regulators, realizing significant gains,” the sources said.

“IDBI Bank will work as a subsidiary of LIC, just as LIC Housing and other subsidiaries, managed at arms length as a board run entity with a professional management,” the sources added.

Elon Musk forms several ‘X Holdings’ companies to fund potential Twitter buyout

3 Mins Read

Thursday’s filing dispelled some doubts, though Musk still has work to do. He and his advisers will spend the coming days vetting potential investors for the equity portion of his offer, according to people familiar with the matter

 Daily Newsletter

KV Prasad Journo follow politics, process in Parliament and US Congress. Former Congressional APSA-Fulbright Fellow

Previous Article

Oil Fluctuates as Traders Assess China’s Vow, Unrest in Libya

Next Article

Shanghai residents turn to NFTs to record COVID lockdown, combat censorship

LIVE TV

today's market

index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -72.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +28.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +30.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -14.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -7.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +8.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +3.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -1.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -72.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +28.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +30.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -14.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -7.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +8.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +3.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -1.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -7.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +8.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +3.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -1.95

Currency

Company Price Chng %Chng
Dollar-Rupee 73.3500 0.0000 0.00
Euro-Rupee 89.0980 0.0100 0.01
Pound-Rupee 103.6360 -0.0750 -0.07
Rupee-100 Yen 0.6734 -0.0003 -0.05
Quiz
Powered by
Are you a Crypto Head? It’s time to prove it!
10 Questions · 5 Minutes
Start Quiz Now
Win WRX (WazirX token) worth Rs. 1500.
Question 1 of 5

What coins do you think will be valuable over next 3 years?

Answer Anonymously

Should Elon Musk be able to buy Twitter?

 5 Minutes Read

Government considers selling controlling stake of over 40% in IDBI Bank to LIC, says report

KV Prasad Jun 13, 2022, 06:35 AM IST (Published)

 Listen to the Article (6 Minutes)

Summary

The government is considering to sell between 40 and 43 percent of IDBI Bank’s stake to Life Insurance Corporation, finance ministry officials told NewsRise.

The government is considering to sell a controlling stake of between 40 and 43 percent of IDBI Bank’s stake to Life Insurance Corporation (LIC), finance ministry officials told NewsRise.

As of March 31, the government held an 80.96 percent stake in IDBI Bank, while the rest was held by the public.

The LIC Board has approved the idea of taking charge of the controlling stake in a bank and will discuss the IDBI Bank stake sale after the government approves the idea, the official told the news agency.

CNBC-TV18 has not received any information on the amount of stake from sources. Sources have, however, confirmed that LIC is open to buy a significant minority stake in the bank.

“The entire equity cannot be transferred to LIC as unless both the regulators,  i.e.,  insurance and banking regulator, agree in which case we are talking of a merger but not talking of LIC holding that substantial equity into it. However, from a business point of view,  it’s a bet the government had said it will work its best effort to revive IDBI bank in some form or other and this is one of those attempts basically.” Ashvin Parekh, managing partner at Ashvin Parekh Advisory Services told CNBC-TV18.

The bank’s board, till the decision materialises, is likely to prepare the capital requirements, financial projections and fundraising plans for the next five years, the official told the agency.

“IDBI Bank was initially looking for large private investors and whether they should be strategic or financial investors was debated,” Parekh said.

The bank has reported large non-performing assets earlier.  On this, Parekh said:

” One thing is clear that the bank is in trouble and there are huge NPAs, the bet the government seems to be taking that if money is provided to the bank at this point in time and if more funds are provided and if the NPAs are funded and proper provisioning is carried out then in four to six quarters, some value restoration may happen. This will happen mainly on account of the recovery basically of all the bad debt that they are sitting on but it’s a bet and one doesn’t really know what will happen.”

 

Elon Musk forms several ‘X Holdings’ companies to fund potential Twitter buyout

3 Mins Read

Thursday’s filing dispelled some doubts, though Musk still has work to do. He and his advisers will spend the coming days vetting potential investors for the equity portion of his offer, according to people familiar with the matter

 Daily Newsletter

KV Prasad Journo follow politics, process in Parliament and US Congress. Former Congressional APSA-Fulbright Fellow

Previous Article

Oil Fluctuates as Traders Assess China’s Vow, Unrest in Libya

Next Article

Shanghai residents turn to NFTs to record COVID lockdown, combat censorship

LIVE TV

today's market

index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -72.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +28.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +30.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -14.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -7.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +8.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +3.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -1.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -72.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +28.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +30.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -14.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -7.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +8.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +3.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -1.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -7.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +8.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +3.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -1.95

Currency

Company Price Chng %Chng
Dollar-Rupee 73.3500 0.0000 0.00
Euro-Rupee 89.0980 0.0100 0.01
Pound-Rupee 103.6360 -0.0750 -0.07
Rupee-100 Yen 0.6734 -0.0003 -0.05
Quiz
Powered by
Are you a Crypto Head? It’s time to prove it!
10 Questions · 5 Minutes
Start Quiz Now
Win WRX (WazirX token) worth Rs. 1500.
Question 1 of 5

What coins do you think will be valuable over next 3 years?

Answer Anonymously

Should Elon Musk be able to buy Twitter?

 5 Minutes Read

Indian Bureaucracy 2.0: What the decision to hire outsiders as joint secretaries means

KV Prasad Jun 13, 2022, 06:35 AM IST (Published)

 Listen to the Article (6 Minutes)

Summary

The move clearly communicates that what might have worked for the past 71 years, may not be sufficient for the future.

As someone who has been collaborating closely with the government for the past decade, the government’s decision to hire outside its ranks as joint secretaries is an exhibition of embracing change and acknowledging an existent lacuna.

Not just in India but worldwide politicians are often blamed for not taking the long view of life given their tendency to play to their term and nothing beyond. This move is yet another example of a bold and adventurous state that is not plagued by insecurities. The time spent with different government departments over the last few years has led me to being humbler about what represents the government – a clear departure from the earlier days of having an antibiotic reaction to everything in the government.

So, what is the primary role of Indian bureaucrats? Their primary role is to ensure ministries act within the boundaries of the constitution and advise them on whether any course of action is practical or feasible. Over the years bureaucracy has been playing lesser role in suggested course of action towards getting things done. The ability of the bureaucracy to think out of the box given they do have the long-term view contrary to politicians and execute has taken a backseat. The influence of changing political ideologies have taken its toll in their independent thinking and they have been playing more the role of what can’t be done than what can be done (of course barring a few exceptions). Somewhere the approach has become inward.

Just like in the corporate world, on and off infusion of fresh talent is a necessity to ensure there is diversity of thought and action, to challenge status quo and stereotypes, to infuse new ideas and best practices believe it’s imperative for our bureaucracy to follow suit. While we have had conversations earlier of the possibility of bringing in outsiders from the private sector – seeing this being actualised is beneficial for five reasons.

One, this signals an appetite for change – It clearly communicates that what might have worked for the past 71 years, may not be sufficient for the future. It indicates an openness to learn and improve the effectiveness of the government functioning with an outside in view. Two, it’s an opportunity to bring in a culture of meritocracy and accountability which is likely to shift focus from activities to outcome. Three, the infusion of private sector talent is also expected to contribute by way of relevant subject matter knowledge, specialised experience and domain networks which are key ingredients in getting things done. Four, there are many professionals in the private sector who have secured themselves and built their credibility to a level from where they are eager to contribute and active participate in serving the country rather than simply being a bystander. This is a unique opportunity for them not only to influence, but also to make change happen. Five, it challenges the great divide (including lack of trust) of the private and public and brings in an atmosphere of empathy and understanding around the strengths of bureaucrats and that of private sector professionals which can potentially be a force multiplier towards achieving said goals.

When the inherent strengths of the private sector professionals are marinated with that of the traditional bureaucrats (which is undeniable),  it creates the ideal recipe of transformation of Indian Bureaucracy to one which has a noticeable action bias towards nation building. However, this move shall be effective provided we are mindful of the following:

There needs to be absolute transparency in the selection criteria – in essence for each role there has to be well laid out qualification and experience criteria of relevant industry or roles. This shall ensure that the right person gets hired for the right role. From the outset there has to be absolute clarity around the goals that are being assigned to the individuals within the period of three years to judge the effectiveness.

Even if one is attracted to these roles – to retain and sustain their motivation clarity around goals is a must. The likes of Nandan Nilekani, Raghuram Rajan, Arvind Pangariya were able to make significant contribution simply on account of the fact that they were give the autonomy and empowerment they needed to deliver to set goals and objectives. Constant political intervention would be detrimental to the initiative and success of the hired professionals. And lastly, one should plan against any misuse of this opportunity for lobbying by those with vested interests from the private sector.

Like every attempt of change, I am not surprised by the kind of backlash even this move has received so far. However, it is important to bear in mind, “The tallest oak in the forest was once a little nut that held its ground.”

Rituparna Chakraborty is Co-Founder and EVP of TeamLease Services Limited

Elon Musk forms several ‘X Holdings’ companies to fund potential Twitter buyout

3 Mins Read

Thursday’s filing dispelled some doubts, though Musk still has work to do. He and his advisers will spend the coming days vetting potential investors for the equity portion of his offer, according to people familiar with the matter

 Daily Newsletter

KV Prasad Journo follow politics, process in Parliament and US Congress. Former Congressional APSA-Fulbright Fellow

Previous Article

Oil Fluctuates as Traders Assess China’s Vow, Unrest in Libya

Next Article

Shanghai residents turn to NFTs to record COVID lockdown, combat censorship

LIVE TV

today's market

index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -72.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +28.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +30.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -14.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -7.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +8.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +3.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -1.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -72.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +28.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +30.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -14.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -7.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +8.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +3.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -1.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -7.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +8.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +3.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -1.95

Currency

Company Price Chng %Chng
Dollar-Rupee 73.3500 0.0000 0.00
Euro-Rupee 89.0980 0.0100 0.01
Pound-Rupee 103.6360 -0.0750 -0.07
Rupee-100 Yen 0.6734 -0.0003 -0.05
Quiz
Powered by
Are you a Crypto Head? It’s time to prove it!
10 Questions · 5 Minutes
Start Quiz Now
Win WRX (WazirX token) worth Rs. 1500.
Question 1 of 5

What coins do you think will be valuable over next 3 years?

Answer Anonymously

Should Elon Musk be able to buy Twitter?

 5 Minutes Read

Air India will not be sold if bid price is inadequate, says government

KV Prasad Jun 13, 2022, 06:35 AM IST (Published)

 Listen to the Article (6 Minutes)

Summary

The government will decide the highest bidder for the national-carrier, Air India, by the end of August, said RN Choubey, union civil aviation secretary. The qualified bidders for Air India’s 76% stake will be announced on June 15, 2018. If the government found out that the bid price is inadequate, it will not sell the airline, …

The government will decide the highest bidder for the national-carrier, Air India, by the end of August, said RN Choubey, union civil aviation secretary.

The qualified bidders for Air India’s 76% stake will be announced on June 15, 2018.

If the government found out that the bid price is inadequate, it will not sell the airline, said Choubey.

According to the memorandum, the government plans to offload 76% equity share capital of Air India as well as transfer the management control.

Government is also free to change the floor price at any point of time, sources said. The highest bidder would be declared as the buyer after requisite security clearances.

The divestment includes the profit-making Air India Express and AISATS, an equal joint venture between the national carrier and the Singapore-based SATS Ltd.

In a related development, sources told Jet Airways has not sent any informal interest to the ministry, after chairman Naresh Goyal had expressed interest in sale of Air India.

Meanwhile, union civil aviation secretary will be meeting the union revenue secretary on Tuesday for bringing aviation turbine fuel (ATF) under the Goods and Services Tax (GST) regime.

Currently, ATF is not under the GST ambit and the levy on it varies from state to state.

A proposal to bring ATF under the GST will allow airlines to claim input tax credit from the government is among the issues likely to be discussed.

Earlier, government cut the GST on the bunker fuel from 18% to 5%, providing huge relief to the traders.

The government is also mulling changes to norms for inviting private players to run Jaipur and Ahmedabad airports.

The ownership will remain with Airports Authority of India (AAI), but private players will operate the airport, said the sources, adding that the government is looking at privatising three more airports after June this year.

Denying the reports that the employee unions are opposing the move, sources said, they are not unhappy and the government will protect employees’ service conditions.

Elon Musk forms several ‘X Holdings’ companies to fund potential Twitter buyout

3 Mins Read

Thursday’s filing dispelled some doubts, though Musk still has work to do. He and his advisers will spend the coming days vetting potential investors for the equity portion of his offer, according to people familiar with the matter

 Daily Newsletter

KV Prasad Journo follow politics, process in Parliament and US Congress. Former Congressional APSA-Fulbright Fellow

Previous Article

Oil Fluctuates as Traders Assess China’s Vow, Unrest in Libya

Next Article

Shanghai residents turn to NFTs to record COVID lockdown, combat censorship

LIVE TV

today's market

index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -72.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +28.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +30.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -14.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -7.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +8.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +3.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -1.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -72.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +28.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +30.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -14.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -7.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +8.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +3.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -1.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -7.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +8.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +3.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -1.95

Currency

Company Price Chng %Chng
Dollar-Rupee 73.3500 0.0000 0.00
Euro-Rupee 89.0980 0.0100 0.01
Pound-Rupee 103.6360 -0.0750 -0.07
Rupee-100 Yen 0.6734 -0.0003 -0.05
Quiz
Powered by
Are you a Crypto Head? It’s time to prove it!
10 Questions · 5 Minutes
Start Quiz Now
Win WRX (WazirX token) worth Rs. 1500.
Question 1 of 5

What coins do you think will be valuable over next 3 years?

Answer Anonymously

Should Elon Musk be able to buy Twitter?

 5 Minutes Read

Reasonable for government to ask OMCs to keep consumers’ interests in mind, says HPCL

KV Prasad Jun 13, 2022, 06:35 AM IST (Published)

 Listen to the Article (6 Minutes)

Summary

As far as news report is concerned, we don’t have any inputs to suggest that there is a reason for us to absorb cost, said MK Surana, CMD of HPCL in an interview to CNBC-TV18.

No respite for oil marketing companies in trade after reports that the government is nudging them to absorb a one rupee hike in every litre of petrol or diesel.

As far as news report is concerned, we don’t have any inputs to suggest that there is a reason for us to absorb cost, said MK Surana, CMD of HPCL said.

Talking about margins, he said, “It’s not a question of peak margin or a margin. The prices are determined based on the day-to-day international product prices in a rolling basis of 15 days. So on a particular day when the crude prices are going up, it doesn’t mean that it reflect in the product prices on that day because it is a rolling average of 15 days past. So how past 15 days has performed will determine the price on that day – that’s one thing. Second, the crude prices and fuel prices doesn’t move in tandem always.”

According to him, it’s reasonable for government to ask oil marketing companies (OMCs) to keep consumers’ interests in mind.

– Structurally it does not justify that crude prices should be going substantially higher.
– If there are no geopolitical adverse situation, I feel it should rebound.
– perception that OMCs are making huge profit on fuel sale is incorrect

Elon Musk forms several ‘X Holdings’ companies to fund potential Twitter buyout

3 Mins Read

Thursday’s filing dispelled some doubts, though Musk still has work to do. He and his advisers will spend the coming days vetting potential investors for the equity portion of his offer, according to people familiar with the matter

 Daily Newsletter

KV Prasad Journo follow politics, process in Parliament and US Congress. Former Congressional APSA-Fulbright Fellow

Previous Article

Oil Fluctuates as Traders Assess China’s Vow, Unrest in Libya

Next Article

Shanghai residents turn to NFTs to record COVID lockdown, combat censorship

LIVE TV

today's market

index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -72.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +28.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +30.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -14.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -7.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +8.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +3.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -1.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -72.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +28.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +30.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -14.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -7.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +8.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +3.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -1.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -7.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +8.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +3.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -1.95

Currency

Company Price Chng %Chng
Dollar-Rupee 73.3500 0.0000 0.00
Euro-Rupee 89.0980 0.0100 0.01
Pound-Rupee 103.6360 -0.0750 -0.07
Rupee-100 Yen 0.6734 -0.0003 -0.05
Quiz
Powered by
Are you a Crypto Head? It’s time to prove it!
10 Questions · 5 Minutes
Start Quiz Now
Win WRX (WazirX token) worth Rs. 1500.
Question 1 of 5

What coins do you think will be valuable over next 3 years?

Answer Anonymously

Should Elon Musk be able to buy Twitter?

Government’s sovereign bond issue is a terrible idea, says Pronab Sen

India’s bond yields surged in Wednesday’s trade, fuelled by inflation concerns. However, yields started softening marginally on reports that the government is mulling sovereign bond issue in the overseas market in FY19.

If the government goes ahead with this move, it will be a first for India. Ashima Goyal, member of PMEAC and Pronab Sen a former chief statistician, discusses the issue.

Q: Sovereign bond issue is this a good idea?

Sen: It is a terrible idea in short.

Q: Why?

Sen: For the very simple reason one of the things that we have to recognise is that if the government owes debt to its citizens there can never be a case of sovereign default. It is simply not possible. The problem always occurs when the government owes debt outside. This is the problem all over Latin America, this was the problem in Greece so anywhere where government have actually borrowed abroad they have run into problems.

Japan like us has stayed off sovereign debt completely. I think it is a terrible idea. It is opening a flood gate which can lead to disastrous consequences.

Q: Would that be an argument that we are testing the waters it will be a limited issue and therefore one shouldn’t imagine that you will go the Latin America way just because we are borrowing USD 4 billion, I mean USD 4 billion would be what Rs 24,000 crore out of a total government borrowing of 6,00,000 crore should one really worry?

Sen: No, the problem is all of these things start with small numbers. India is a very large economy. So, it doesn’t sound like very much. The point is that do you as a matter of policy open a door which says that if I run into a balance of payments problem I will go abroad and the government will borrow money from the market rather than go through other means. We have done all kinds of borrowings which have been government induce, but it has never been sovereign debt. I think it is a door best left closed.

Q: What about the argument that foreign borrowers are also great disciplinarians and therefore the very fact that a rating action or earning the ire of a foreign investor of foreign markets can discipline governments better?

Sen: It is already happening. I mean remember the foreign markets are already influencing you through foreign portfolio investment (FPI). Now whether that money is coming here for government securities or for private securities doesn’t really matters that much. The fact is that in terms of our balance of payment (BOP) finance the FPI money is important. That is about all the discipline that you need.

Q: On a separate note the idea of a sovereign bond is being whispered precisely on a day when there is the news of oil going above USD 71. The government will after a point not want to pass on especially in a year dotted with elections and then it will have to bring down its excise hikes, its excise duty on petroleum. That will mean a fiscal breach. Do you think our fisc is already under threat in the current year with oil being the way it is?

Sen: Not really, you actually think about it. If anybody expected oil to hang around USD 40 a barrel there were living in a fool’s paradise. We were seeing predatory pricing being done by Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) essentially to drive the shale oil producers out of business. It worked up to a point, but then they couldn’t maintain it for very long.

Now what you should expect to see going into the future is essentially a two person game. OPEC on one side and the shale oil producers on the other. I would imagine that you will see oil yo-yoing within a fairly limited band of somewhere between USD 60 and 80. As far as our fisc is concerned, let us recognise another fact of life which is that the government increased the tax to mop up the difference between USD 80 which was its own reserve price and whatever the global price was.

Now surely, until we hit USD 80 the government cannot complain that they have been unfairly hit. If they had gone and overspend that money or over committed those funds that is just bad planning.

Q: That is usually the case, the money that was earned from lower crude prices through excise hikes have already been spent or committed?

Sen: No, spend by all means, there is no need for you to hang on to it. But don’t spend it on anything which is of a recurring nature which becomes an ongoing liability that is the question.

Q: The argument that Pronab Sen is making that it always starts small and we all know the example of Latin America and what sovereign borrowing did to those countries, therefore don’t even start, that door is best left shut.

Goyal: I believe in homeopathy, so a little bit of poison helps you become stronger. When you test the markets, you require experience, you get rated abroad etc and it imposes some fiscal discipline. However I believe that predominantly you have to develop domestic market. General advice is that your domestic market must be deep before you allow any of this foreign or even domestic debt inflows. We have been holding it as a low percentage of the total turnover which is very healthy. We must recognise that it is a tail, it can’t wag the dog and we must now allow it to wag the dog because sometimes the problem is even though it is a small amount, policy tends to over-react or over worry about what will happen to those flows.

Q: USD 140 million of IMF loans was a tail that did wag the dog many years ago, we were a smaller economy then.

Goyal: That was a larger percentage of the total market. Now you have grown, so this USD 4 billion or whatever is a very small percentage of the total market.

Q: We already are getting market discipline as Pronab Sen pointed out. FPIs invest upto 5 percent, now 5.5 percent of domestic bonds, is not that market discipline enough? Do we really have to expose ourselves to a dollar denominated sovereign bonds?

Goyal: As long as it is a very small quantity of total government borrowing and it remains that then it is not unhealthy.

Q: Do you think the fisc is under threat with crude going to USD 71 per barrel and a year dotted with elections when the government will be vary of passing it on to consumers?

Goyal: I heard Pronab Sen talking about this. I agree with him largely on his points. I would just like to add that for us USD 70 per barrel because we earn from nations that gain when oil prices are higher in terms of remittances etc. So, the government gets taxes. We have had a slowdown, we were expected to gain from very low oil prices but we did not, slowdown continued. So, I think we are seeing a recovery as oil prices become more normal. At this level it is healthy for the oil market itself because you have supply being built otherwise you have supply and then an overshooting when demand rises. So, it is healthy for oil markets, healthy for global demand and it is healthy for our remittances and other export earnings which will lead to an increase in government revenue. So, it is not necessary that rise in oil prices stays within our comfort band and is necessarily bad for fisc.

Q: The point that Ashima Goyal is making that a little bit of poison is good so long as we are able to keep that sovereign bond amount limited to USD 4 billion, you agree or disagree?

Sen: I disagree. She may believe in homeopathy, I believe in yoga which is abstinence.

Demand for cement is going to be solid for the next 5-10 years

Cement demand may rise before elections

With the focus of the government, the entire public spending going on infrastructure including road and irrigation projects keep the demand for cement solid, said Sudip Bandopadhyay Group Chairman of Inditrade Capital.

We like cement companies as a secular growth story for the next five to 10 years, he said.

 5 Minutes Read

Aadhaar not panacea for all ills, Supreme Court tells Centre

KV Prasad Jun 13, 2022, 06:35 AM IST (Published)

 Listen to the Article (6 Minutes)

Summary

Section 7 of the Aadhaar (Targeted Delivery of Financial and Other Subsidies, Benefits and Services) Act, 2016, says that the proof of Aadhaar number is necessary for availing certain subsidies, benefits and services.

The Supreme Court on Thursday told the Centre that Aadhaar is not a panacea for all ills in the system such as corruption, tax evasion, money laundering, leakage of subsidies and terrorism, and wondered how far it can cast the net of Aadhaar.

Saying that “Aadhaar is not a catch for all frauds”, the five-judge constitution bench comprising Chief Justice Dipak Misra and Justices A K Sikri, A M Khanwilkar, D Y Chandrachud and Ashok Bhushan, asked: “How far the State can cast the net of Aadhaar that goes beyond Section 7 of Aadhaar Act and the money laundering?”

“Frauds are not happening because of multiple identities” a person possesses, the court said as Attorney General (AG) K K Venugopal tried to impress upon the constitution bench the virtues of having one identity — Aadhaar.

Summing up the broad submissions of the AG, Justice Chandrachud said: “The core of Centre’s case is that there are legitimate State interests which are to be protected. Lakhs of crores of rupees are spent which should reach the poor. You want to prevent money laundering. You want to protect collection of taxes.

“The question is how far you pass the test of proportionality. Many of the problems are unrelated to Aadhaar, which may not satisfy the rigours of Section 7 of the Aadhaar Act, 2016. How far you pass the net?”

Section 7 of the Aadhaar (Targeted Delivery of Financial and Other Subsidies, Benefits and Services) Act, 2016, says that the proof of Aadhaar number is necessary for availing certain subsidies, benefits and services.

“There are wide economic disparities, 67% of the country’s wealth is concentrated in the hands of less than 1% people. The disparity has further widened after the country became independent,” Justice Sikri said as the AG tried to defend and justify Aadhaar by pointing to the large section of vulnerable population.

Finding the AG’s submission that “Aadhaar will prevent bank frauds” unpalatable, Justice Sikri said: “When loans are given you know the person. You give loans after due diligence. NPAs (non-performing assets) don’t happen unless banks are hand in glove with those who secure loans.”

Blaming the banks for the lack of due diligence in granting loans, AG Venugopal said: “That (due diligence) ought to have been taken at the level of banks. If it had been done, Nirav Modi would not have happened.”

“Aadhaar will not prevent a person from starting different commercial entities. Starting different companies or entities by one person is not per say illegal. The problem is that for every layer of transaction, separate credit is given by the banks. There is multi-layer transactions and you get credit for every transaction… Aadhaar is not a catch for all frauds,” observed Justice Chandrachud.

Defending the decision of linking all bank accounts with Aadhaar, the AG said: “Our point is that every banking transaction will be discovered through Aadhaar. To that extent, Aadhaar is useful.

“For the larger interest, the question is whether we have one identity for all.”

As Venugopal tried to focus on the over-arching benefits of linking Aadhaar with various services and activities, Justice Sikri said: “You want Aadhaar authentication for each and every activity of mine. This is the concern expressed by them (petitioners).

“You have issued 144 notifications. You want cell phones to be linked with Aadhaar. You consider every individual of population as a terrorist or a violator… Here comes the question of proportionality.”

The court also took exception to the Aadhaar Act giving “excessive powers” to the Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI) on expanding the list of biometric data it can collect, saying that tomorrow it could start asking for samples of blood and saliva. “It has already added fascial impression in the list of biometric data.”

Asking, “does a terrorist apply for cell phone”, Justice Chandrachud said “but they can as well use wireless phone”.

The AG said a lot of terrorists and their supports have been nabbed by linking Aadhaar with SIM card.

The constitution bench is hearing a batch of petitions by former Karnataka High Court Judge K S Puttuswamy, Magsaysay awardee Shanta Sinha, feminist researcher Kalyani Sen Menon, social activist Aruna Roy, Nikhil De, Nachiket Udupa and others challenging the constitutional validity of the Aadhaar scheme on the touchstone of the fundamental right to privacy.

Attorney General Venugopal will continue his arguments on April 10.

Elon Musk forms several ‘X Holdings’ companies to fund potential Twitter buyout

3 Mins Read

Thursday’s filing dispelled some doubts, though Musk still has work to do. He and his advisers will spend the coming days vetting potential investors for the equity portion of his offer, according to people familiar with the matter

 Daily Newsletter

KV Prasad Journo follow politics, process in Parliament and US Congress. Former Congressional APSA-Fulbright Fellow

Previous Article

Oil Fluctuates as Traders Assess China’s Vow, Unrest in Libya

Next Article

Shanghai residents turn to NFTs to record COVID lockdown, combat censorship

LIVE TV

today's market

index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -72.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +28.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +30.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -14.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -7.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +8.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +3.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -1.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -72.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +28.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +30.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -14.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -7.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +8.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +3.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -1.95
index Price Change
nifty 50 ₹16,986.00 -7.15
sensex ₹1,882.60 +8.30
nifty IT ₹2,206.80 +3.85
nifty bank ₹1,318.95 -1.95

Currency

Company Price Chng %Chng
Dollar-Rupee 73.3500 0.0000 0.00
Euro-Rupee 89.0980 0.0100 0.01
Pound-Rupee 103.6360 -0.0750 -0.07
Rupee-100 Yen 0.6734 -0.0003 -0.05
Quiz
Powered by
Are you a Crypto Head? It’s time to prove it!
10 Questions · 5 Minutes
Start Quiz Now
Win WRX (WazirX token) worth Rs. 1500.
Question 1 of 5

What coins do you think will be valuable over next 3 years?

Answer Anonymously

Should Elon Musk be able to buy Twitter?